Tuesday, December 2, 2008

Final Crisis: Rage of the Red Lanterns #1

The whole thing just feels kind of silly. I mean, we are really going to have an army for every color of the rainbow, each with their own rings? And these aren't old groups, they are all inspired by the GLs, it seems. The whole thing just seems kind of inherently silly. Another problem is the typical gore we expect from every story from DC these days. Since the Red Lanterns are the new foes, they succeed in slaughtering some other ring-slingers. The Sinestro corps pastes a few GLs too. I'm just getting tired of the constant deaths in the corps. Between this and GLC, I'd never want to be a GL these days, the death rate has got to be through the roof. The one development I'm intrigued by is that the Controllers (former founders of the Darkstars) seem like they're going to be the Guardian-type for the orange corps, that could be pretty neat. Atrocitus has a silly name and doesn't interest me as the leader of the Red Lanterns. Their whole vomit-blood power is pretty silly and over the top. I find the whole concept pretty laughable.

Shane Davis' art is really nice. He does good work, I was impressed with his Mystery in Space work a few weeks ago, and he brings that level of detail to this special, and everything looks good. Without a doubt though, the high point of the book is the hissing rage-cat. It's weird, this issue is competently done, but with all the death and dismemberment, I just feel like I've seen it before.

Fair

Tangent: Superman's Reign #9

I can't really make myself care about this book at all. I actually bought all the Tangent books back in the day, but I can't remember any of the characters, and none of htem have really stepped up to become interesting leads in this series. The main players in this issue are Superman, Power Girl, and Guy Gardner, and you'd think that would be entertaining, but it really isn't. This issue is almost all filler as Tangent Superman tries to force New Earth's leaders into following him. They don't like the idea and argue for too many pages. Then the JLA-headliners blow up jets as they try to get to the aircraft carrier where the leaders are being held. Guy Gardner comments about how bored he is fighting the jets, and I agree with him. The whole sequence is just boring. Eventually they get a nuke to the face, but I'm reasonably sure there will be no fallout (ding!) to such a big cliffhanger. This series has shown flashes of being interesting, but it is way, way too long.

Carlos Magno handles the art, and he does ok, but I think his stuff was best when he could spend lots of time on Mary Marvel's huge assets in Countdown. He just doesn't seem as interested here.

Average

Conan the Cimmerian #5

I'm finding myself much more interested in the flashbacks featuring Connacht than the main Conan story. It might be the excellent artwork by Richard Corben, but I think I also like the unpredictable nature of the flashbacks. Connacht's adventures could lead him anywhere, and we really don't know what is going to happen. I feel like I know how Conan is going to respond to most everything in the ongoing story. It's weird, Tim Truman has really upped the ante on the weird stuff that I usually love, but I just haven't been able to get into his Conan as a character. He does have a good antagonist this issue, where Conan actually seems threatened for a moment. When Conan eventually bests him, the villain asks of Conan"Do not leave me like this. Send me to Ymir a man." Conan obliges with a quick chop of his sword. A nice moment of respect between foes.

Corben's art in the flashback is stellar. Connacht's escape from the slave ship looks great. The detail on the dying slaves and then on the slave-master were tremendous. Corben's textured pencils are unlike anything else on the stands. The flashback art raises the value of the whole comic. I may pick up the trade on this one. It's that close to being a Good.

Fair

Monday, December 1, 2008

Batman: Cacophony #1

Well, that was dirty. I was expecting it, every blogger and his mother has been talking about the most offensive things in this issue. (In case you missed them, Joker talks about his pubs, "presents" to a villain, Mr. Zsasz only has one place left to cut - and yes, it's where you think.) So that's the stuff that was stupid and inappropriate. The good stuff was using Maxie Zeus in kind of a new way, Deadshot being shown as a neat, conflicted assassin (who plans ahead!) and Batman as a little more vindictive as normal. Bats' brutal takedown of Zsasz was pretty satisfying and a great way to introduce him into the comic. So it's about what you expect from a Kevin Smith comic.

This Walt Flanagan guy on art, who I understand is a friend of Kevin Smith's, is pretty good. He's a little on the exaggerated side, but I especially liked his hunched Zsasz and the weirdly deformed flunkies Joker uses to terrorize a private school. His handling of the leads is average, but those little spots with more freedom are interesting. Overall, the weird story stuff lowers the grade. I don't think some of that material is appropriate for Batman, and Joker's actions come close to ruining the character.

Fair

Ambush Bug: Year None #4

Keith Giffen and Robert Loren Fleming serve up more of the same type of hijinks as the previous issues, except with more Dan DiDio bashing! I do like some of the more pointed jokes, like why it's ok to skip reading Countdown. The one-off pages are amusing too, most especially the dramatic scene with Wicker Bug and Wicker Sue (from the pages of 52!) The Ambush Bug Revenge Squad is pretty pointedly making fun of obsessive readers, a pet peeve I've seen Giffen write about before, and yet I can't help but notice that those same fans are the ones who would be picking up this series.

Giffen's art changes as the story demands. Of course my favorites are those scenes he draws in the style of his 5-year later Legion. But the switching styles work well for comedic purposes here. His Jann Jones in manga style is particularly amusing. Overall, this is for the hardcore DC nerd though, and that's just not me anymore.

Average

Punisher MAX #64

Now that Garth Ennis' hand isn't guiding the Punisher franchise, something is missing. The cursing feels more forced, the bad guys seem more artificial, and Frank doesn't feel like himself. The story is fine, and as a action-movie plot, I'd have no issue with this story. For a Punisher story, something is just ringing hollow. I'm not sure where the difference in tone is exactly hitting, since Ennis had Frank handle all sorts of bad guys, often in foreign lands, but this is off. Perhaps after years and years, I just associate the Punisher with Ennis' interpretation. This story feels like it has gone on too long. I can't tell any of the bad guys apart. I think using Jigsaw in this kind of role weakens him as a recurring villain for the Punisher. What was the strongest part of this story, Frank's interactions with the townspeople, is still here, there's just a lot less of it.

The art is fine, but a little on the muddled side. I did like the bits with the shark in the swimming pool though. The scene of Frank walking way from a bloody hot tub with a shark in the nearby pool was nice and chilling (yet again, it had an action movie feel).

Average

Batman & the Outsiders #13

I can't tell what the point of this comic was. We've got some weird interactions with Man Bat, Spoiler, Vigilante, and Batgirl, something where Batgirl is forming her own Outsiders, but man, I just can't make myself care. I think Frank Tieri is picking up Intergang plot-threads from his Gotham Underground series, but I avoided all those Countdown tie-ins like the plague, so I'm lost. There's all sorts of weird status quos for Penguin, Man Bat, Mr. Freeze, and Killer Croc that I'm lost on. I don't really like any of those characters except Spoiler, and she comes off pretty naive and with a level of Batman-respect that I just don't remember her having. The only way I could ever care about this new Vigilante is if he's really Wild Dog like some people are speculating, but if that is the case, I'd rather he was just Wild Dog.

Ryan Benjamin's art is fine, but doesn't really stand out. With a story this empty, the art has a lot to make up for, and this doesn't do it. It's a Batman R.I.P. tie in because Batman isn't in it? I don't see any other connection.

Poor